Jump to content


  • Among Us: From Fun To Irritating

       (Overall rating from this review)
    A game essentially adapted from the concept of "Who is the Werewolf" or those classic mystery movies where you're trying to figure out who done it... but there is something missing.

    Among Us is a video game where you join up with strangers or friends, you each pick a different colored character and then you run around a space ship or alternative level in a 2 dimensional world trying to fix numerous issues, and complete various tasks before one to three people in the group successfully end the lives of most everyone else on the ship.

    The core concept of the game reminds me of this Werewolf game where everyone is handed cards and you try to figure out essentially, who the heck is the werewolf in the group. If you want to check this game out, it's actually incredible and in my opinion much better than Among Us: https://amzn.to/3v8dPiq

    In the "Ultimate Werewolf" game, you can look each other in the face and ask each other questions to decide who is the danger to the other game players. Thing is, in Ultimate Werewolf you also have special abilities and secret allies. Meanwhile Among Us? Very very boring abilities and very uninteresting roles to play. You're either the person hunting everyone else down, or the hunted. No in-between and that makes the game painfully boring.

    If the company behind Among Us wants to make the game more interesting, they have to actually give the individual crew mates individual abilities. For instance one crew mate could have the ability to detect the moment someone is downed by the Imposter. Another person could be a body detector, have a general censor to find out where bodies are to help them resolve issues faster. Another crew mate could have the power of completing other people's tasks when they are done with their own and so on, there are enormous possibilities and it would make the game so much more playable.

    My experience playing Among Us is that you are so often and repeatedly placed as a crew mate that you could play a 10 round game and never once find yourself being the imposter. This is why the imposter should have the option of allies, but not necessarily people who can harm any crew mates. For example, an ally of an Imposter could tie up or otherwise bind crew mates for the Imposters to later find. There could also be a crew mate who has the ability to fight off Imposters. You would have this modification of the game to make it far less boring and far less likely you get the same role over and over again.

    I played a game once, 6 rounds where I was a crew mate every time and another player was the imposter 3 times... seriously? It is so lame to just run around, waiting to get clipped and me being normally a popular target because it's hilarious to take my character out as I generally run the servers, I'm just a sitting duck.

    Long story short, the game is really fun at first, but with disproportion and almost no imagination, the game gets dry really fast.

    A lot of folks think Among Us is great, probably mostly because they've never played Ultimate Werewolf in real life and don't remember what it's like to actually solve a mystery with the person physically in front of you, or maybe they just like the simplicity and repetition of the game that never seems to evolve or add any real surprises.

    But ultimately, if the game doesn't get an update that adds a new element or fixes the issue of making the same people the Imposters over and over, why would I want to ever play it again? Why does anyone?
     

     

    Pros:
    • Promotes a much needed gameplay concept in the video game world.
    • Great character design.
    • Few errors in multiplayer connectivity.
    Cons:
    • Really lacking in imagination with zero growth.
    • Boring and extremely limited character roles.
    • Asks you to pay for really pointless add-ons.
    • Puts all the work on players to be entertaining in order to have any fun.

    Gallery

    • Entertainment
    • Production Quality
    • Audience Benefit
    • Depth & Originality
    • Emotional Vibe
    • Replay Value



    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    • Moderators

    I've never played Among Us, only watched YouTube videos of people playing it and I'm not really into it. I guess it can be entertaining at first but after watching the game go on for a while, I would get bored. Maybe I would have a different opinion if I actually played it, but then again I don't care to.

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • Administrator
    1 hour ago, Kaitlind said:

    I've never played Among Us, only watched YouTube videos of people playing it and I'm not really into it. I guess it can be entertaining at first but after watching the game go on for a while, I would get bored. Maybe I would have a different opinion if I actually played it, but then again I don't care to.

     

    It's more fun to be the imposter because you actually can do cool stuff. Everyone else just runs around doing mundane tasks...

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • Moderators
    Just now, Onision said:

    It's more fun to be the imposter because you actually can do cool stuff. Everyone else just runs around doing mundane tasks...

    Yeah that seems to be the most fun part 😁

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • Immortals

    omg u did not compare a video game to a board game lmao, also just have 2 or 3 imposters instead of 1, that's how most people play and that's why people love the game, nobody plays with just 1 imposter no wonder u would never get him. Although I agree with all your star ratings, except for replay value, if I'm correct they kept adding maps adding to replay since that's really the only thing that gets boring in my opinion, the core game itself is fun to most people if not you. Its just simple. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • Administrator
    13 minutes ago, Tyler said:

    omg u did not compare a video game to a board game lmao, also just have 2 or 3 imposters instead of 1, that's how most people play and that's why people love the game, nobody plays with just 1 imposter no wonder u would never get him. Although I agree with all your star ratings, except for replay value, if I'm correct they kept adding maps adding to replay since that's really the only thing that gets boring in my opinion, the core game itself is fun to most people if not you. Its just simple. 

    I almost always play with 2 or 3 imposters. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • Moderators

    It does get boring after awhile, but I do really enjoy playing it on discord with a lobby full of my friends and 2 imposters. It's not that the game keeps us entertained, so much as we keep one another entertained as we play 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • Moderators

    I've never played but I've watched people play on twitch and it doesn't seem fun honestly lol. It's like barely even a game....its just people doing menial tasks and talking to one another...and my anxiety is 📈📈📈 when I talk to people...idk I don't think I would enjoy it which is why I've never tried

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Activity

    1. 10

      Eugenia Cooney's Impact on Fans

  • Topics

  • Tell a friend

    Love Onision Forums? Tell a friend!

Chat

Chat

    You don't have permission to chat.
    ×
    ×
    • Create New...